The government must put victims at the heart of justice reform

This article by Dame Nicole Jacobs, domestic abuse commissioner for England and Wales, is part of our Voices series on how to fix the prison system. In the wake of the overcrowding crisis and the early release scheme, we invited five people with diverse experiences of the system to share their thoughts in the Winter 2026 issue of New Humanist. To read the rest of the series, buy a copy or subscribe now.
For victims of domestic abuse, the time their perpetrator is in prison is often their first moment of relief. It provides people with the opportunity to find somewhere safe to live, a chance for them and their children to regain their confidence, and the much-needed breathing space to start building a future free from abuse.
Against this backdrop, it is not difficult to understand why the early release scheme, and the government’s decision to not exclude domestic abuse perpetrators, has been so acutely felt by victims. On a near daily basis, I hear from survivors terrified about what their perpetrator’s release might mean for their safety. Nearly all describe feeling like the rug has been pulled from under them as they are forced to put in place measures to keep themselves safe, far sooner than they expected to have to do so. Many are changing their routines or implementing safety plans at their children’s schools, while others feel they have no choice but to uproot their lives completely.
For many of these victims, their abuser’s sentence will not have come quickly or easily. It will have meant months building the courage to report the abuse, days spent reliving traumatic moments in police interviews, followed by a long wait to learn whether their case would progress and, often, years before it reached a courtroom. Many will have done this alone, as specialist domestic abuse services continue to face a cliff-edge in funding, while legal aid has been stripped to the bone.
But while victims tell me they are scared, few say they are surprised at having been left to shoulder the consequences of the ongoing prison crisis. Because for them, this debate extends beyond the current problem of managing capacity. It is about continually having to navigate a system that too often does not put them first and too often lacks the means to keep them safe.
The pressures facing our prisons are not happening in isolation. Across the country, police forces are facing intense financial pressure after years of cuts. Our court system has all but ground to a halt with over 80,000 Crown Court cases stuck waiting to be heard in England and Wales. And now, with the early release scheme, the probation system, which was already under immense strain, is being asked to supervise increasing numbers of high-risk offenders who have been let out into the community, without the level of funding needed to manage those risks effectively.
I want to be clear that the issue is not a lack of commitment. Across the justice system there are dedicated professionals working incredibly hard to keep victims safe. But they are working within systems that too often prevent them from doing the basics of their jobs well.
While consecutive governments have tried to tinker at the edges, none have set out a credible vision for how policing, courts, prisons, probation and specialist services should work together to protect victims and hold perpetrators to account.
It is time for this to change. Right now, we have a prime minister who says he wants to have the difficult conversations about the biggest challenges facing our society. Justice reform must be one of them, and victims must be put at the heart of these changes.
A victim-centred justice system starts by understanding what a victim needs from day one, and ensuring every agency works together to deliver that support, safety and protection throughout. But this cannot be built on overstretched services and short-term funding. It requires investment across the system, and long-term funding for the specialist domestic abuse services that often have to fight to keep their doors open.
Putting victims at the centre of reforms also means giving them faith that the system will truly stand alongside them and deliver the accountability they deserve. Faith that they will be taken seriously when they come forward. That their case will be dealt with sensitively. That police and probation will act swiftly if a breach occurs. That they will be involved and kept informed about decisions that affect their safety. That they can live safely in their own home and community.
In the wake of the overcrowding challenge and the early release scheme, the government faces a moment of reckoning. Does it continue to lurch from one crisis to the next, applying short-term fixes to long-standing problems? Or does it seize this moment to build a justice system that truly puts victims at its heart?